Historical Commission's Role Is More Hindrance Than Help

Should a city board tell you what color to paint your house?


A few weeks back I attended a meeting of the Salem Historical Commission. My reason for going was simple — the fate of an old barn on what used to be the Ropes Estate on 18 Felt St. was up for discussion.

The Ropes Estate was sold earlier in the year and broken up into separate lots. The house and garage have since been purchased by landscape architect, Michael Blier. Blier has been busy repairing and restoring the property as a home for his family. 

The barn was purchased by James Treadwell, a noted advocate for historic preservation in Salem. He has been, for many years, a leading voice in Salem for restoration and rehabilitation. Many times over the years, when a developer or property owner proposed to demolish an older structure, he was the one who stood up and objected. St. Joseph's Church would be the most recent example.

It was interesting to me that Treadwell had decided he would like to tear the barn down because it is "not feasible to rehabilitate". 

As the meeting progressed, the barn on Felt Street was relegated to just a part of the story.

First on the agenda was a couple on upper Essex Street who needed the board to approve the materials they had chosen for repair of their front porch. Little did I know, that decision does not belong to the homeowner.

Next up were folks who own a house on Derby Street down by the power plant. The board told this couple very specifically what kind of clapboards and corner boards were to be used and also instructed that they were to retain "existing rakes and cornices".

The next 25 minutes were spent tearing down a Broad Street homeowner's plan to build a mudroom vestibule on the side of her house. A discussion about the appearance of a door that will not be seen from the street was actually amusing. The pitch of the roof was critiqued, the size of the vestibule called into question and, in the end, the whole plan was continued to a later meeting. I wonder how much it cost to delay the contractor.

More recently, a vacant and neglected property at 6 Federal Ct. has come into the local news feed. In the 1990s, the Salem Historic Commission denied the owners of this property permission to raze an old carriage house on the property because they felt that the property should be preserved. They also later denied a request to adapt the carriage house into a single family home. What we have there now is a run-down abandoned property. It seems to me someone is trying to make a point to somebody here.

Historic preservation is an important part of what Salem has become. We need to preserve and restore when and where we can. We learned that lesson 40 years ago when a younger generation of civic leaders stepped up to stop the destruction of our downtown district.

Rules and procedures were put in place to assure that history in Salem would always be a priority. It is time, I believe, for some changes to take place. We must still protect our history, but having a small group of people telling you what color you can paint your house is a little too much protection.

Homeowners should not be put through the wringer every time they need to strip some clapboards and apply some paint. If they want to add a mudroom it should not require multiple trips to public meetings with architects in tow and drawings in hand.

I want to see the barn at 18 Felt St. survive, but I don't own it. James Treadwell bought it and paid for it. Despite his frequent positions on what others should do with their property, this decision should belong to him. 

The Salem Historical Commission should have their sails trimmed a bit and let property owners be property owners. 

windpower October 25, 2012 at 10:11 PM
Yet the planning board will pass anything for the administration 2.1/5 density etc
Mack Donald October 25, 2012 at 11:11 PM
If you are upset about the church going, well, I think this goes a little deeper than just your huge desire to preserve. That church was very ugly. It got shut down because that tax exempt organization it belonged to was letting it fall into disrepair. Then you expect the next developer to "preserve" that ugly structure in order to make it useful again. You might have wanted them to keep that dead man on the cross up against the front of the building too, right? Now you say you lean towards "stricter" measures by the hysterical commission. You also ignore the fact that we live in a new age now where energy conservation is very important. Instead people are forced to keep single pane windows while at the same time they can put ugly storm windows on the outside. Where is your logic man?????????
Loving Salem October 29, 2012 at 03:26 PM
As usual, most of you eventually degrade your comments fueled by your political bias. What a shame that people cannot have a civil discourse about an important subject without name calling or bringing completely irrelevant and/ or unsubstantiated "facts" into the discussion. As for historical houses it may be of some use to think about our roles as caretakers of what makes Salem unique among cities - our history and our residences. We care for these homes in order for future Salemites that can enjoy and build on that uniqueness. That is why it is important to have a community that cares for the integrity of this history and supports and advises homeowners of their connection to it as well as the preservation of our unique city.
scott November 04, 2012 at 01:27 PM
Hello! So you want energy efficient windows? Salem news reported a story about new windows melting the siding of a house on the building next door, from the reflextion of the sun. Well, that means that your house is loosing all the natural energy coming into the house from the suns. There was just a multi- million dollar case against the energy effient window industry for deceptive practices. They can no longer promiss that you will save a % on your heating bills. These windows were designed for the Southern hemisphere were they wanted to keep the heat out of there homes. If you want to talk about sustainabilities, there is NO window on the market today that could ever compare to these old wood windows. A good combination window will do the same thing as the energy efficient replacement window for a fraction of the cost!
Mack Donald November 04, 2012 at 07:18 PM
Are you nuts?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »