PHOTOS: Before and After Salem Power Station
Here's a closer look at what the Salem Harbor Power Station is expected to look like after the original structure is demolished.
The computer-rendered photos above were included in the Visual Impact Study segment of a Footprint Salem Harbor Station Powerpoint slide presentation that was presented to a small crowd of area residents Tuesday night at Bentley Elementary School.
The photos offer a before and after look at what the redesigned power station is expected to look like - the biggest change being the fact that new plant would have only one smokestack in place of the current facility's three. And that stack would be less than half the height (230 feet) of the tallest existing one (492 feet).
Vantage points highlighted in the study include Bentley Elementary School, Winter Island, Marblehead and Cat Cove.
Click Here to view the entire Powerpoint presentation, which has been posted on the city of Salem website.
What do you think of the computer-generated "after" photographs? Are you pleased to see that the nearly 500-foot smokestack will be torn down? Will you miss seeing them as part of the Salem skyline?
Let us know in the comments section below.
roger boulay
7:06 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
it doesn't matter how to me how tall the smokestack is if it is still going to be spewing it's filth into the atmosphere...
william Lach
8:29 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
granted it's a controversial structure that is past it's life, but nothing says "you're home" than seeing that plant from the right side of an airliner coming in from Europe. Progress marches on, and it will be missed.
David Moisan
10:34 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I won't miss the plant--except for that aspect. That plant has been a landmark for many, many years, an iconic landmark even. I flew to Cincinnati on a business trip years ago and I was delighted when our plane took the northern track to Logan--right over the plant!
I used to love standing in the middle of the (new) Beverly-Salem Bridge with my camera overlooking the plant.
It will be missed.
Josie Wales
2:30 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Hey Bill I know you and we were brought up in the nieghborhood. Roger needs to get a life. This whole project is a great thing for Salem and this area.
Nelson Dionne
10:00 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Might the tallest stack be suitable for reuse as an observation tower ? It already has an elevator.
william Lach
10:40 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Nelson, a great idea!! another tourist attraction, call it, A Witch's Eye View of Salem!!
adrienne
10:50 am on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I know it's time for those smoke stacks to go, but....coming home late at night from work & driving down Derby Street & seeing those stacks all lit up & blinking...what can I say? I've grown to love the urban/industrial look! I'd probably love looking at a wind turbine, too!
Josie Wales
2:32 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I'm wondering if those UFO's from the 40' s?? will get all mixed up when they visit again.
Carolyn Costain
3:22 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Years ago "learning to fly" those stacks were a dead reckoning point for me. Taking down those stacks may be a bit confusing to student flyers and cause changes to maps. The stacks re-assured me to where I should "not" fly, so I didn't accidentally end up in Logan airports airspace. Those stacks are historical as well.
roger boulay
5:40 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
hey bob, what is your problem... what did i say to offend you...all i said is that if the smokestack spews its' toxins into the air what difference does it make how tall it is..
ken
6:04 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
You are being extremely melodramatic and negative about someone else investing millions of dollars in the City which will lead to vast improvements to the amount of toxins released from a place that now burns coal and oil sludge. Not to mention opening up what is now the vast coal storage area for a waterfront park. Are you one of the guys who went to the meeting and wanted to know why they couldn't get the same power output with turbines and solar panels?
Josie Wales
6:34 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
You didn't offend me. It is just that Salem is now getting rid of a dinosour and getting a great park, cruises and seaport, and tree's , landscaping, and oh I forgot , a better cleaner power plant.All for free! This is much better for the young one's who will inherit it when we pass away.
Carolyn Costain
7:49 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Hey Roger, the toxins in the air is only one of the down falls. That land might be loaded with fly-ash. The Salem plant, back in the 50s contaminated both sides of Henderson rd (alias, Airport road) in Beverly. The contamination was less than 2000ft from our water supply and a small river ran through it, that lead directly into the Wenham lake. Because of the fly-ash our power plant dumped there, the property had high considerations of arsenic and cyanide in both the drill test sites and top soil. So i do believe that property our power plant is going to be a nightmare!
john
8:06 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Carolyn, the toxins in the are will be eliminated,the land will be cleaned,the coal pile will be gone and even if there is fly ash at least we will not be producing it anymore. Looking back in time is not productive. Years ago you could spray waist oil on dusty areas to stop the dust because the theory was we were putting it back where it came from. In my opinion we have moved past the enviromental concerns because there is no question this is a cleaner ,tax generating, plant. Salem power plant has been the biggest tax payer in Salem for years. We can't have everything. We need a strong commercial tax base because Salem is turning into a low income,high crime homeless center. This is the best possible thing that we could hope for at that site and ,as a homeowner, I feel much better thinking it will happen.
Carolyn Costain
8:21 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
John, are you joking? The land in Beverly that the Salem plant contaminated was 30 feet deep and ended up having to be capped with 4 feet deep of clay! I believe the power plant was dumping on that land in Salem before they started carting it to Beverly and other sites. Arsenic and cyanide are only 2 of hundreds of chemicals that Fly-ash breaks down into. I read every test result out of the Beverly site and worked on the environmental issues for over ten years over there "so i do know what I am talking about." The power plant might have the fly-ash just as deep as the Beverly site " that took decades" to resolve the issues and capping etc. So this is not just getting out a broom and planting the daisies!
john
8:31 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Caroyln, let me try another approach. First we are not talking about Beverly.Secondly I understand your concern but if you look back at what could happen to that area ,I don't know how you can not support this plant.Dominion had the opportunity to close the plant ,lock the gate and leave town.No clean up at all. Would you support that? I have already addressed thae fact that we have learned from past mistakes.Remmember when Peabody was the leather capital? They moved on and so should Salem.
Josie Wales
8:37 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
My family has lived a stones throw from the Power plant since 1920 and never had any of the problems everyone is talking about. Only once did we get ash maybe 20 yrs ago. We have 5 generations here and no health related problems. This whole project is going to beautify the whole aera.
Josie Wales
6:36 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Only thing that bothers me about the whole thing is they took away the Striper Fishing!!!!
roger boulay
6:52 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
wow..the question put forth by the patch was are you pleased to see the 500 foot smokestack torn down...my reply was simply if the new stack produces the same amount of toxins then what difference does it make..if it in fact cuts down on toxins then i am all for it...how is that extremely melodramatic and negative...
john
6:58 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
It seems that you are uninformed on the pollution issue. Gas is MUCH cleaner than oil and coal and what comes out of the gas plant will be mostly steam as compared to black smoke and ash.
Josie Wales
7:06 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Right on John. Roger is worried that his tomatoes and cucumbers won't grow due to lack of fertalizer from the coal ash.
Josie Wales
8:16 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
John is right again. My family has lived a stones throw from the Power plant since 1920 and never had any of the problems everyone is talking about. Only once did we get ash maybe 20 yrs ago. We have 5 generations here and no health related problems. This whole project is going to beautify the whole aera.
Carolyn Costain
8:44 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
You might not have problem now "the site is covered in grass. God help when they go digging it up?? I should hope that residents will have easy access to tests of the soil on that site and not have to go through the freedom of information act to get them. My point of mentioning Beverly to the John on here , was that "They may have" dumped on the Salem land before "having to" cart the ash to other sites and that the Beverly sites were 30 feet deep. How deep is it, at the Salem power plant? I think that land is another nightmare like Beverly was.
john
8:51 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I get your point but you offer no alternative. The site is actually covered by the plant and the unused tank farm that will both be removed. Today much of the Beverly land has been developed,so tell me what your option for the Salem land is?
Josie Wales
9:03 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Did Carolyn watch the whole presentation? I wonder. I think it's amazing and a great oppertunity for us in Salem. Beverly misses out on this. They can't even figure out what to do with the old McDonalds at the bridge for how many yrs now?
Carolyn Costain
9:05 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I am not against change John, i am just saying that , that land is a potential nightmare. It's a wait and see game. I have a family member living near the plant so I do worry a bit about its future. With gas? There is a bigger risk to the people living near there if there is accidents like we been seeing with "Gas" over the years. People also forget that at one point in the past, our power plant was on a potential terrorist list. With gas there, it just makes it easier to target than coal I would think. So yes, I have a few concerns. PS there is "nothing" built on the capped site in Beverly , the development is further down the road.
john
9:07 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I didn't watch the presentation but I have followed this topic closely and it really comes down to simple common sense.
Josie Wales
9:11 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Watch the presentation. You will be dumfounded. It is really great looking and will really enhance this whole area.
Carolyn Costain
9:22 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
OH' and if its going to look like the picture above? its gad awful ugly. The old power plant is a lot better looking.
roger boulay
9:26 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
hey bob, you're a funny guy...i don't know what i did to get you take so many pokes at me but at least i have the balls to put my last name to my posts...the reason you don't have any health issues related to the power plant is because the wind blows the crap over to the pickman park area and towards marblehead..ask those people about it...also you spelled fertilizer wrong....if you would like to take more pokes at me let me know maybe we can get together sometime and have a few laughs.......
Carolyn Costain
9:32 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Yeahhhh It's about time someone said it to Bob. I call him the "One name wonder!"
Josie Wales
9:44 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I may be wrong but I think I know you and was just trashing to get you going thinking you would figure out who I was.. As for Carolyn, I told her once, she is a great trash talker for Fantasy Football.
Carolyn Costain
9:50 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
OH' Bob, I know you love me! But your just not my type! I tell it like it is and you trash talk everyone.
Josie Wales
9:53 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Fantasy Football is over till next year. I guess I miss it. This keeps me in practice I guess.
john
9:26 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Carolyn,I agree that the land is a potential nightmare. However the nightmare is much worse if we don't move forward. The EPA will monitor the development and again I remind you that Dominion could walk away and that property would become a super fund site and sit for decades. My knowledge of Henderson is that FEMA is on the right side of the road and Sam Fonzo Dr is on the left which connects to Cherry Hill Dr.I don't doubt your claims about contamination in that area but the area seems to be moving forward as we should in Salem.
Carolyn Costain
9:42 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
They could at least humor people and put a creative looking building, like in the shape of the "Salem witch" or something. The picture above is ugly , plain, without character. Thousands of tourist will see this site on the way to winter island or the Willows. I just think if they are going to move forward into the future they could at least add something fitting with the historical aspects of Salem. That pictured building , is ugly.
roger boulay
9:44 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
it's easy to be a tough guy when you hide behind anonymity...his name probably isn't even bob...don't worry about the contaminated land.....they'll just cover it with plastic sheeting and 2 feet of dirt plant a few trees and call it a day....i had a friend that lived in the condo complex where parker brothers used to be ..i don't know if it's true but he told me that there was a clause in the lease absolving the new owners of any liability concerning contaminated land and sickness.......again, i don't know if it's true but that's what i was told
Carolyn Costain
9:53 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
I heard the same thing from my father years back. "He also worked there when it was "I believe" Parker brothers.
roger boulay
10:22 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
hey bob, make it easy on me...what's your last name....
Carolyn Costain
10:29 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Roger, nice try but I don't think he will give it and if he does? It's probably a fake name.
roger boulay
10:34 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
carolyn, i just friend requested you on fb...i don't know if you are aware but there is a site called"you know you're from salem if you remember" you have to be invited in that's why i friended you...everybody on there is from salem..probably some people you know..if you want to join friend me and i will invite you..if not that's fine..it's been fun playing on patch..
Carolyn Costain
10:49 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
Invite me.
roger boulay
10:37 pm on Thursday, February 28, 2013
i would invite bob but i need his last name...lol
Bryan Karsis
10:13 am on Friday, March 1, 2013
... Getting back to the smokestacks ... I'll miss them purely for the landmark value. Whether seeing them from the air, or from 128 North just after the 95 split, or driving back from Beverly after work every night, or heading in on the ferry from Boston, the stacks were always a welcome sight, pointing the way home.
Doug Bowker
11:28 am on Sunday, March 3, 2013
A gas fired plant will not be spewing.g anything toxic at all. Its steam and CO2, which is essentially "clean" though it does contribute to greenhouse gases and global warming. But we all need electricity in case a few here are confused about that. Gas power is a great inbetween step and great for the city's future.
Josie Wales
12:41 pm on Sunday, March 3, 2013
Right on brother!!
Carolyn Costain
1:09 pm on Sunday, March 3, 2013
I don't like only being able to read about what "use" to be there, like the witch museum "use' to have towers on both sides of the front of it, that were twice as tall and beautiful! If you look up "Salem" on Wikipedia "the power plant picture is there." If I read about something and go to a city to visit? I want to SEE what I read about!
Ed Carroll
9:53 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013
at least with the old stacks the pollutants went over your head,now with the new lower stacks the pollutants blow in your face..pollutants from coal or gas are still pollutants..we don't need pollutants from either source, sooo take down the coal plant and keep the gas plant out
Ed Carroll
10:04 am on Tuesday, March 5, 2013
hey Salem patch...how about doing some articles about Salem high school's choral group "witch pitch" after winning a competition in Connecticut its on to New york